top of page

sports: man's arena for feeling

I was recently discussing with a male friend of mine his decision to change his career trajectory.  From high school and onward, through two advanced degrees, he had been hell-bent on a career in politics.  He even lived for a time on the West Bank working with refugees and studying immigration policy. But after finishing his Masters in Philosophy from Cambridge (casual) he hit a wall.  Turns out he didn’t actually have as much love for politics as he thought. What he did love though, was how discussing politics allowed him to connect with his father.

 

Now, I don’t know how common it is for men to forge their paternal relationships through politics—probably more popular here in California than in, say, Arkansas—but the father-son relationship, at least in America, has always been tricky.  Relationships are built through frequent open and honest communication. This is not something American men are great at. Largely because for some reason American men have taught themselves that it’s not acceptable for them to show one another a full range of emotion.  Except, that is, when it comes to sports.

 

At a [insert sport] game, men are not only allowed, they are encouraged to actively and noticeably release emotion.  They may dress it up as a display of their masculinity, but where else can men shout and cry and cheer where they are 100% free from ridicule.  Not only are they not put down for these dramatic displays (because let’s be honest, it can be a lot), but they are surrounded by others doing the same.  It is the one place where men allow themselves to be vulnerable and open while also allowing others to experience it with them.   

33-rod-stewart-crying-best-sports-gifs-o

Another friend of mine, this time female, was expressing her own frustration at not being able to relate to or understand her boyfriend’s very emotional reaction to the recent loss of his favorite team.  Now here is a man who is actually quite in tune with his emotions and is, as far as I know, pretty good at expressing them. Yet here is he acting like your run-of-the-mill suppressed American male.

 

Well, one of the reasons that this particular American male is more in tune with his emotions than his peers is that he was introduced to therapy at a relatively young age after the loss of his father.  His father with whom he regularly attended baseball games, which made up a substantial part of their relationship.

 

It seems almost comically obvious, now, why his team’s loss might conjure a deeper more extreme sadness than my friend could initially understand.

 

Men in America have set it up so that not only are they funneling all emotive release into the outcome of a sports game, they are concentrating into this environment the entirety of the complex father-son relationship.  And where there is concentration there is often pressure.

 

And pressure builds.


Men and women have the same feelings, the joys, disappointments, fears, and outrages of life.  But somehow (most) men have limited themselves in a way women have not, specifically in a community-based sense.  Women talk about their feelings with other women constantly. Adult women call home twice as often as men.  When we get together with female friends we discuss our own fears and insecurities in a way that men do not.  Sometimes all it takes is a compliment from the woman in line behind me and *poof* she has heard my entire life story.

I am going to go out on a limb a say most men cannot relate to that scenario.  *I*, however, cannot relate to reacting to a man catching a ball like this:

1.gif

Or like this:

2.gif

I know there are female sports fans who have gotten carried away at a game or two.  But I think we all can agree that in general, men are affected differently by the outcome of a game.  And I think that I (all of us really) could do a better job in encouraging men to spread the wealth a bit when it comes to their feelings.  And maybe the next time the man in your life is weeping because Johnny McFootball dropped the pigskin, instead of rolling your eyes, get him a cookie or something and just say “that fucking sucks”.

© The Champagne of People - October 2018

bottom of page